That’s completely wrong, no matter what you were told in yeshiva. The biology of your body has nothing to do with what your religion is.
Guy on internet vs. R’ Chaim. Hum, lets see who I would believe.
The issur is viewed as a chiddush, and not as accepted.
Of course not! Chadash is Assur Min HaToirah!!!
To me, the distinction is one of ignorance. Sorry that I speak thus of Roshei Yeshivos.
And as such, you can’t blame the bochrim for thinking it is Muttar, no matter what is said. Action speak, words without actions don’t.
There are Yeshivas in Manchester that boot boys out for smoking – the Rosh Yeshiva’s son was ‘asked to leave’ for driving and smoking during zman.
One Yeshiva, and he had to be driving too!? Obviosly he was kicked out for driving, as smoking is not enough. Yeshiva’s in EY also kick bochrim out for driving (which is much worse than smoking, as driving could lead to mixed dancing, CV, Lo Alayinu)
(Poe’s)