Reply To: chicken

The mishnah has 2 cases – hiniach bireshus and hinicah shelo bireshus. In the first case I am patur for the hezek caused to the baal hachatzer’s animal, in the second case I am chayav.

In this case, I was meniach bireshus but it was understood this was for a limited time only. The hezek was caused becuase I left it beyond the permitted time.

In the case of the mishna, of hiniach shelo bireshus, my hanacha is the kerias bor – so is the maaseh mazik. In a case where I was machnis bireshus and the hezek only could have come about becuase the object was left there for too long, is there a petur that there is no maaseh mazik?

My initial hanachah was not a maaseh mazik because it was bireshus, and just leaving it there longer is not a maaseh.

Vos sogst du?