Loyal Jew -“R. Gatesheader, by the egel, the slate wasn’t wiped totally clean. There was a stain that remained forever, even after tshuva, even after Moshe’s pleadings, and even Shevet Levi killed the 3000 direct perpetrators. So of course a bachur can be mekabel to stay off unfiltered internet and express regret for what he did. He should even do as the Rambam said and become fanatically anti-internet for a while. But the stain on his neshamah remains.”
WolfishMusings
The Wolf
“But the stain on his neshamah remains.
And guess what? That applies to *every* sin.”
Wolf -you just fell into this guy’s Farfrumta Kruma trap.
Ya see some people (Krum, of course and full of hate) use things like this Asifa to pretend they are Tzaddikim and others are Reshayim. While you are correct that every Aveira causes Timtum Halev, you missed what that guy said. He said that the Timtum remains even after Teshuva and he compares it to the Egel. Of course this he said without any proof. The truth is – Once a person does Teshuva – the Timtum Halev goes away from every Aveira, including Shmiras Eneyim.
If this guy wasn’t such an Am Haaretz -he’d fall into the category of Megaleh Ponim B’torah Shelo K’halacha.