Reply To: How do u judge a singer if hes good?

One more critera to add: goosebumps. This past Shabbos, the baal tefila sang Mimkoimcho that was so good, the feeling was almost tangible.

For a split second, I was able to “hear” that tune being sung the by the voices that sang the same tune back in pre-War Europe.

Doesnt happen often, but when it does, its to the credit of the baal tefila