Reply To: Yeshiva Boys being sent home to collect Bain Hazmanim

‘Tina: If the guys don’t collect it, you are taking away the Mitzvah of giving Tzedaka from so many people who would have given had someone collected and otherwise didn’t give.

And, there is a humongeous Mitzvah in collecting Tzedaka for the Yeshiva too. ‘

Im not sure your understanding. The Bochorim are giving (there koichas) – The askanim are giving pay + extra.

So from the Bochorims perspective – they are giving and collecting as opposed to just collecting

Is anyone suggesting that collecting alone is better then giving AND collecting?