Home › Forums › Decaffeinated Coffee › Is it mutar to be an organ donor? › Reply To: Is it mutar to be an organ donor?
I see. And it is impossible for me to dispute that, since I can’t even say that you don’t know nearly enough to argue, because the whole premise of your position is that it is so simple that anyone could argue–like yeravam ben nevat.
Sure, but anyone can say that about any halacha. You could, for example, say that you are going to go worship idols, and that the poskim are clearly in error and that the argument is so simple anyone can see it.
So, since I don’t see it as so simple, I’m going to think that you’re the fool.
And I suppose you think there is a taaina on me, because the argument is so simple that I shouldn’t be listening to poskim on it either.
That’s ok. I think you’re acting like a child. Nobody who agrees with about the halacha, would say what you are saying. None of the rabbonim behind the halachic organ donation say what you are saying–that the other poskim are in clear error like yeravam ben nevat and should not be followed. You are truly one person in the entire klal yisroel who is saying it.
Well, either everyone is wrong, or you are wrong. And I’m part of everyone, so I have my opinions on that.