Reply To: (??????? (????? ?????

Home Forums Bais Medrash (??????? (????? ????? Reply To: (??????? (????? ?????

#852299
hello99
Participant

yitay: “The Rashba is in Volume 1 Teshuva 495”

Yitay: To borrow from the Rashba you mentioned ?? ??? ?? ???????.

Furthermore, even if you will insist that the Rashba is describing a general definition of Ein Kavanaso, then his ruling is incompatible with the Terumas HaDeshen cited in SA YD 84 and many other cases I quoted previously from SA and other Poskim. So even if this would be the intention of the Rashba, which I still highly doubt, there is no reason to assume it is the accepted Halacha.