Sam2 -“Health: You can’t just dismiss anyone you disagree with as “totally disregards Halachah”. The IDF Chief Rabbi is a Bar Hachi of having an opinion and is entitled to Pasken how he thinks is right.”
I don’t know if you read all my posts or just some of them or parts of them. The issue here is that Not one MO Rabbi or Mizrachi Rabbi said “Mutter”. Let me give you a Moshul – The Burger King on your corner is a great eatery. All of a sudden a Rabbi says e/o should eat there. You see no change in the place, no Tzetetlach hanging; the same cheeseburgers as before. You don’t have to be Dan this Rabbi L’caf Zecus. He has to explain what he said is true. He would have to say – a group went in -in the middle of the night -Kashered the whole place. Now everything is Glatt and the cheese is fake and a Kashrus sign will be up next week. If he doesn’t explain this -I have no reason to think this is the case. As a matter of fact I would not be allowed to say in this case -“I’m going to eat there because Eid Echad Neeman etc.”
The same thing here -one Rabbi got up and said “Mutter”. If he wants to be taken seriously -he has to explain Why! Since he didn’t – I don’t have to think his opinion is based solely on Halacha. I was trying to come up with other reasons -why he said what he did!