pba: your new case for number 6 makes more sense. I would say you don’t call it a sfek sfeka. Ask the widow if she plans on having the baby.
So suppose it is something that doesn’t work it it is gazul. Like a lulav. And suppose he finds out that day. And suppose I’ll figure out a case where you can only do it if it is a chiyuv.
So make up a case and we’ll talk. Since this thread is about “daas Torah,” a Rosh yeshiva I was zoche to learn with taught me not to “talk in the air” without a case.
Zeeskite: If I thought presenting rishonim (including the ones Rabbi Miller uses in his books) would help, I would.
Reb Shepsel:
2- Kiddushin 7a or thereabouts. Look it up.
What do you mean about being sure?
Ctrl Alt Del: Fech, stop being such a machmir!