Search
Close this search box.

Yerushalayim: Chevra Kaddisha Buries Secular Man Instead Of Charedi In Body Mixup


A serious error occurred in Har Hazeisim when a man was mistakenly buried instead of another. The mistake was discovered only several hours after the burial. The body was exhumed and the distraught family held a second funeral.

The two deceased men died on Monday at the Bikur Cholim hospital – one Charedi and the other secular. Some of the secular man’s family members were overseas at the time and his funeral was thus postponed for the following day. The Charedi family decided to bury the man on the same day he died.

The Jerusalem branch of Chevra Kadisha handled one of the bodies from the hospital discharge stage until the burial. All was going according to plan until the secular man’s family arrived to ID their loved one and were shocked to find an entirely different person.

The unfortunate mistake was soon discovered and the Charedi family was informed of the blunder. On Tuesday night the body was pulled out of the grave and returned to the hospital and the Charedi man was buried instead.

Members of Chevra Kadisha said that the first deceased man to be buried was ID’d by the Charedi family prior to the burial. They added that both men were not in any way similar in appearance. “One was huge and one slender, one with a Charedi appearance and one secular looking,” one source said. They are yet unclear how the error occured.

Chevra Kadisha director Rabbi Shlomo Ben Ezra told Ynet this was a highly unusual event which he had never encountered before. He added that due to the sensitivity of the circumstances he is not pointing fingers at any specific individual and promised to probe the matter.

No comment was received from the Bikur Holim Hospital. The report was first published in “Kol Haredi.”

Have you checked out YWN Radio yet? Click HERE to listen!

(Source: Ynet)



7 Responses

  1. Even if they would both have been chareidi this would have been a terrible blunder. Who knows how many times this has happened (anywhere in the world) and noone knows?!!

  2. It is unusual that a close member of the family goes to identify the niftar. It is also unusual for someone to really look at the niftar and that is probably the problem. Whether it is fear or a sense of kibud that a person does not want to actually look into the face of the niftar that is what actually causes these mistakes.

  3. Does secular mean non-jewish?
    Also, #1, what’s your point? YW would’ve probably written the same thing if they were both Chareidi!
    Also #3, if they were both jewish, this has nothing to do with Zechusim! Every Jew should get a proper Tahara and Kevurah regardless of how many Zechusim he has!!!

  4. YW fan…

    You wrote “this has nothing to do with Zechusim! Every Jew should get a proper Tahara and Kevurah regardless of how many Zechusim he has”

    Of course he SHOULD get a proper tahara and kevura, but if he has a chiloni family, he may not have gotten it.
    Perhaps as "rb" suggested, this individual did have certain zechusim that got him what he deserved from a heavenly source.

Leave a Reply


Popular Posts