yid.period – “Health – I assume you have learned some gemara over the course of your life.”
Don’t assume anything. Maybe I’m an Am Haaretz like you.
“Can you really say, with certainty, that no RY has come out against what you are quoting R Lamm as saying !?”
Since you didn’t read My post -I’ll quote it for you:
“so I can only assume that e/o there including the Rabbis have no objection because Shtika K’hodoah!”
I heard No Public objection!
“(I say “you assume” because what you just typed is definitely not a direct quote, and you’ll have to forgive me for taking your interpretation with a grain of salt).”
Don’t be so lazy and go to the pervious page and see what he says!
As far as I can see from his quote -there are no other possible interpretations. If you can squeeze one in – by all means let e/o know!
“Eidim can only testify that one did not pay back a loan in their presence, not that it was never paid back at all! IF what you are saying is close to the truth, you still cant throw everybody associated with YU into that group…”
Again you didn’t read my post -I’ll quote it again for you:
“Yea -that’s right – the CEO represents the school!”
“and btw, in any case, how much is R lamm involved with YU these days? I didn’t go to YU in previous years, all I know is what it’s like now – and so I can say it IS run according to halacha – and you haven’t brought any evidence to the contrary either.”
Well how can you say this? Did you ask the current President and the board that runs the school what they hold regarding Reform & Conservative conversions? If you didn’t ask, then you have to assume they hold the same as Rabbi? Dr. Lamm!
It’s really getting fun having these convos with you yid.period!
And that is an exclamation mark, not a period. (period)