“to prove that there is nothing wrong with discussing goyish culture on a Yeshivish site?”
80, I find a few things wrong with that question. First, I never said there is nothing wrong with it, I asked which is worse. Which means that I think there actually can very well be something wrong with it (at least some of it). Second, I don’t think I’ve ever discussed “goyish culture”, merely a few names of non-Jewish songs and bands. Third, I don’t think this is a solely “yeshivish” site. It is Yeshiva World, not Yeshivish World, and there are many people who associate themselves with a yeshiva, but not yeshivish.
I really do not intend to be disrespectful at all! If you know me well enough, I really try to be as sensitive and respectful as possible.
But even so, I will try to always remember not to post my discussions about non-Jewish music here. I realize it upsets people, and I respect that.