Basket:
Again, some concept of Jewishness are just not up for discussion. If you want to serve G-D, just not the Torah way, well you could be a righteous gentile. Us Torah-true Jews have a specific way of doing things handed down to Moshe Rabeinu at Har Sinai. If your ‘soul guides you’ etc.. and you don’t feel like submitting yourself to daas Torah, feel free to start a new religion. Based on “my own intropection, intelligence, insight and hard work”. NOTHING related to being JEWISH!