david1999:
“It was used as a sociological weapon by the Zalonim against the Aharonim.”
How can that be if both Rebbes oppose the eruv?
What’s fictional considering the Divrei Yoel is on the record as opposing the eruv?
“Alas that is not to be in NY, since there are people who formed a group called hilchos issurei eruvin.”
And?
“For starters see to whom this teshuvah, Igros Moshe, O.C. 5:28 is written to.”
What about them?
You think Rav Moshe would fall for a bunch of lies or wouldn’t double check the “facts”?
“I would just add that the majority of the inhabitants of Boro Park do not belong categorically to any one group, hence they carry.”
What does not belonging to one group have to do with anything, unless you mean the people who use the eruv don’t have a rov. And are you asserting that most B.P. chasidim are not chasidim of a particular rebbe?
And how does the fact that in Flatbush they follow the Roshei Yeshivos make the people of the neighborhood less amenable to an eruv? And WHY are the R”Y all opposed to the eruv? Did that question cross your mind?