apushutayid- I will not name the rov because I would imagine he would not appreciate me doing so. I understand that you have no reason to believe an anonymous poster in yw coffee room. It was not the main point of my argument. Maybe we have a different understanding of the term kula. I am not saying an eruv is only kosher bishaas hadchack (i assume that’s what you meant, an eruv can’t be kosher bideved, that makes no sense). All I am saying is that using standard derech hapsak it would come out that one should not use an eiruv that relies on the 600,000 hetter. That being said, every competent rov can make their own determination whether or not to use the hetter. A rov can say to only use it bishaas hadchack, or he can to say to use it lichatchillah, because the minhag is like the yesh omirim, or whatever other reason he comes up with. The fact of the matter is, that is called relying on a kula, which your rov may tell you there is nothing wrong with.
Menu