Dr. Pepper –
Sorry for my curtness (especially saying wrong), I regretted that quickly — but not quick enough to edit. I just was disappointed in the “tone” of your original post, but even that was due to a misunderstanding on my part, considering your recent clarification. My apologies again.
I hope you agree with this…
I do in fact.
I’m apologize for being purposely vague over here…
I didn’t quite get that, but do agree with your point. Although such instances are so rare, I’m surprised it was brought up.
Again, over here, I was being vague…
Again, I missed your point before. Probably due to speed reading. You have a valid question here. Although similarly, someone who entered the general workforce in a low compensated position would be in the same boat in this regard.
Thanks for the clarification.
ROB –
I explained in great detail how kollel guys are not on tzedakah. They are being compensated for a service. (In addition to my point from the Ramah and Shach.)
hashemis1 –
Good question. And there is a good answer to your question. I just don’t remember it at my fingertips. I believe it is along the lines that you can give it as maaser since the “benefit” is spiritual. But don’t quote me on that.