goody613 – “not acording to the gemoroh in gittin. Elu ve’elu divrei Elokim chayim”
Obviously, that can’t apply to everything; Elu ve’elu is a process. If one member of chazal says a peice of meat is kosher but the p’sak din is like those who say it’s treif; are you going to eat it because they are both right, eilu v’eilu?