Reply To: Homemade Bagels Home › Forums › Kosher Cooking! › Recipes › Milchig (Dairy) Recipes › Homemade Bagels › Reply To: Homemade Bagels July 12, 2009 2:19 pm at 2:19 pm #675195 kapustaParticipant this is going back about a year, I think they were more “bumpy” but when they came out of the water, they were pretty smooth. I would also say to try adding flour. G’luck. *kapusta*