ok. i wasnt following this whole thread but let me jsut say that imo i think that to take a goyish niggun and make it or try to make it jewish is oh so dead wrong . and u know what its not just hte lyrics, because when u hear a song that was “converted” u can tell right away. a friend of mines friend was singing a song to someone and shes like what did u just sing! and she started to sing the real goyish original. how horrible and how sad . i think that it is very spiritually damaging for pple to listen to goyish music or goyishe converted music. as mbd said that in gemara it says that one that listens to a a certain type of songs which im sure pple can guess without me writing it- they dont get their full olam haboh. i think its more worht it to live ure life a jew the corect way
Menu