- This topic has 25 replies, 12 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 8 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Normal plain chips from a packet. There seems to be a difference of opinion. Shehakol or haadama?
What type of chips?
hagafen.
I don’t know what bracha hagafen chips are.
Regular potato chips (not Pringles) are hoadama.
Herrs potato chips (you can take a factory tour and see it for yourself) are sliced potatoes that are seasoned and fried.
How are Pringles different than other potato chips?
Pringles arent potato chips, they are potato “CRISPS” . Regular potato chips are sliced potatos boiled in oil. Pringles are different, they are potatoes that are smashed into a paste and formed into that shape and then cooked
Notice regular chips are all sorts of shapes and sizes and pringles are always perfect
Regular potato chips are made from slices of potato that are fried (or sometimes baked).
Pringles are made from potatoes (And probably other chazzerei mixed in) that are made into a powder/ or paste such that they do have the appearance of potatoes any more and then that paste is fried or baked into the familiar Pringle chips.
What makes the Pringles halachicly different than potato chips as far as a bracha?
I think you make a shehechiyanu on Pringles, because nishdayngesheft and zahavasdad agree about them.
lol @ DY
There are many types of chips nowadays. Are you referring to potato chips, corn chips, sorghum chips…? Are they made from sliced potatoes or smashed potatos (like pringles)?
(As an aside, pringles should be hamotzi because once you pop you can’t stop so it is a full meal :). )
OP is asking about wine chips. Otherwise he would have specified potato chips or corn or tortilla or flotilla chips or whatever. You’re all morons for not seeing that, and in particular dy and the brocha on all of you is
…meshaneh habrios?
I think it’s pretty simple.
If the potato is sliced and fried/baked then it’s hoadomo. If it’s pringle style ground and then reshaped and baked/fried then it’s shehakol.
The same goes for corn flakes.
Kugel is the same. If it has recognisable pieces of potato, it’s hoadomo. If it’s too finely grated, then it’s shehakol.
Why are “plain chips” assumed to be potato chips? Maybe they’re plain corn chips or plain banana chips or or plain bagel chips or plain wine chips.
Or wood chips
Or chocolate chips.
Or the OP could be British.
OK, chocolate fries.
Some people make a shehakol of potatoes.
Shehakol is said on potatoes if they are raw. They couldn’t properly be called chips.
Most people would probably assume “plain chips” to mean potato chips, but when asking any shaila it’s very important to be specific.
There’s a well known story of the Tzehlimer Rav zt”l no longer paskening shailos by phone after misunderstanding a caller that asked about a piece of “bret” falling into a dish (I’m not sure if it was a pot or bowl) of Pesach soup. The caller was Litvish and asking about actual bread, the Rav thought he meant a piece of wood — and told him to simply take it out of the soup.
In this case it wasn’t a lack of specificity but different Yiddish accents that caused the confusion, but my point is that a more concise question lowers the chance of a misunderstanding leading to a wrong answer — which was most likely the reason for all the tongue-in-cheek replies here — to teach the asker a lesson.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.