- This topic has 30 replies, 11 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 10 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Let’s stop avoiding the question. Are children under bar/bat mitzvah really Jewish. They do not keep any torah. Let’s face it they seem not to be Jewish.
Plenty people don’t keep the Torah and are Jewish. Some even don’t believe in Hashem r”l. Some people even put trolling questions on chat forums, but are nevertheless Jewish.
And some people don’t even remember where the trolling think was trollen from and are still Jewish.
What about girls under bas mitzvah – are they doubly not Jewish?
Boys under bar mitzvah are just the seeds that blossom into cars. Girls turn into car manufacturers.
If children are not jewish, then how are their children jewish?
Ford factories don’t employ children, so you can’t bring a proof from that.
Ford employees used to be children.
Is a baby bot that didnt have a bris yet Jewish?
Bots are not Jewish. They do not have mothers.
Ford employees used to be children.
Ford employees used to be children.
Everybody used to be children. Except children. So according to your logic, everybody is children except children.
I made a statement. I did not apply any logic.
Bots are not Jewish. They do not have mothers.
Cars also don’t have mothers, and according to your earlier statement they’re jewish.
RebYidd: Boy. Boy. BOY. boy. Apologies.
Cars mothers are the car manufacturers. Bots are different because bots are not manufactured.
Bots aren’t manufactured because boys are born.
Sorry rebyidd,
They are
Google it
You’re probably referring to a different kind of bot.
So it’s probably the same bot as hashemisreading
mitzvah of chinch
Preparation of watering a seed.
The potential to become something does not make it already so.
are they jewish after they have their bot mitzvah?
Bots are not adults.
Bots are not adults.
Why are you so hung up on age?
Would you prefer if I were not so hung up on age?
Would you prefer if I were not so hung up on age?
This isn’t about my preference. It’s about who is Jewish, which is very important.
Here’s why it’s so important:
(http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/1-million-frum-jews-in-the-state-of-new-york)
Have you asked anyone else?
The GRANAT brings down in hilchos geiros that there are 2 parts of being Jewish: mishpachas Yisroel and das (religion) Yisroel so even if children don’t do mitzvos and are therefore not part of das Yisroel they are undoubtedly part of mishpachas Yisroel.
they dont have beards…….
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.