- This topic has 18 replies, 15 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 4 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Does anyone have the lyrics please for that song?
???? ???? ????? ?? ???? ?? ?? ??? ????? (????) ????? ?????? ?????: “??????, ??????, ???? ??? ??????? ???? ??? ??? ???????
“??? ????? ?????
Melech HaMoshiach is not from Shevet Levi.
Is he allowed on the roof of the Beis Hamikdash?
golfer: Maybe he’ll be a b’chor, and will be able to do avodah then.
Do these lyrics have any source? To me they don’t seem to make sense in two respects:
1) I always assumed the Bais Hamikdash will be built after Moshiach comes.
2) According to the diagrams I’ve seen in sefarim the Bais Hamikdash doesn’t have a roof. Unless by roof it means he’ll be standing in the heavens.
Gamanit- it does have a roof. mefurashe gemaras in zevachim.
The lyrics are from Medrish Rabba.
It really with the word aleiyich. Not sure why that didn’t make it in to the song.
Gamanit
1)Assume nothing. Everything is in seforim. Moshiach will arrive first according to many Rishonim. According to Rambam he will in fact oversee the building of the 3rd BH. (He doesn’t hold like Rashi and other Rishonim who hold it will descend in fire)
2)The BH has a roof. The courtyard obviously does not. Check google images you’ll see.
WIY- I didn’t assume based purely on my own opinion. I just wrote assume because that’s my style of writing. I don’t know why I thought there was no roof though, my mistake. I did find on chabad’s website the source for the lyrics. It’s from a yalkut shemoni. Can anyone explain though what it means? Why would he have to say that the geulah is here when the Bais Hamikdash is already built?
Gamanit: Either it’s meant to be a metaphor (which is clearly obvious, I think) or this Midrash is literal and assuming that the Beis HaMikdash can be rebuilt long enough before the Geulah that it wouldn’t be immediately obvious.
Or it’s like a rousing speech and the “Im Ein Atem Ma’aminim” is rhetorical.
Medrash rabbah yeshayahu perek Samuch
If you think about it, the medrash is astounding. The third bais hamikdash is here; Moshiach is standing on top of it telling us that the long awaited geulah has finally arrived … and yet” v’im ain atem maminim…”. How could anyone not belive at that point?
missed sam’s proposed pshat but still find the “rhetorical” explanation to be strained .
Maybe we can resolve both pshatim by saying that mashiach will use Google SketchUp to build the 3rd Bais Hamikdash and then it will come out of his computer and descend from heaven in fire.
there are many places mashma beis hamikdash will be rebuilt before moshiach. see ??????? ???? ??? ?”? ?”? and yerushalmi in berachos explains the reason the bracha of yerushalayim is before malchus bais david (es tzemach) is because first the beis hamikdash will be rebuilt and only afterwards will malchus bais david (moshiach) come
Clearly as 42 alluded, moshiach will do some video editing to show himself being on top of the sketchelach of the bais hamikdosh. Then he will post the video on jewtube. The real bais hamikdosh will come later and of course he wont stand on its roof.
This is in yalkut shemoni Yeshaya Tuf Tzaddik Tes, Samech. There was a thread on this several years ago. I was once looking for the mekor to this. So I googled Where are the words to anovim and I got this thread. http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/source-for-anovim-anovim
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.