- This topic has 18 replies, 14 voices, and was last updated 12 years, 9 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
What’s the thing of a baby not looking in a mirror, is it a true thing or just made up?
The Be’er Moshe (8:36) says it is a valid minahag.
He also says red string and not stepping over someone is valid.
http://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=14712&st=&pgnum=420&hilite=
He calls these minhagim “old wive’s tales”. He hardly refer’s to them as valid. They are minhagim that’s it.
its a “buba maysa”
not quite. he says you can’t make fun of it. I think what it boils down to is ‘Who knows?’ rather than saying that it is valid.
musser zuger: Did you read the same thing I did? Old wives tales as the Rashba says is not how your explaining it.
?? ? ?? ? ? ? ? ?? ?
.?? ? ? ? ? (??? ??) ?? ? ? ? ???? ?? ? ?? ?? ? ? ???
The Be’er Moshe (8:36) says it is a valid minahag.
Yet another reason I’m going to hell. I should have covered the mirrors in my house when my kids were babies.
The Wolf
The Be’er Moshe (8:36) says it is a valid minahag.
Yet another reason I’m going to hell. I should have covered the mirrors in my house when my kids were babies.
The Wolf
He didn’t say it was an invalid minhag not to.
I had an uncle who was very particular about this matter. He also gave us all “roiter bindlech,” which I keep with me at all times. He also gave me a Raziel Hamalach, which I keep in my teffilin bag. I don’t much go for these segulot, but he did, and I loved him very much. I keep these momentos as a matter of respect for him and to preserve his memory.
WolfishMusings
You only need one reason. But no matter what you have done you can do Teshuvah.
I knew this thread was familiar
http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/babies-looking-into-mirrors
You only need one reason.
I don’t know what you mean by this.
But no matter what you have done you can do Teshuvah.
Not if I don’t regret it. And there are plenty of things that I do/have done that I do not truly regret.
The Wolf
“You only need one reason.”
I don’t know what you mean by this.
I think he means that you only need one reason to go to gehinnom. For some reason, he’s not taking into account the level of punishment.
The reason you don’t truly regret it is because you don’t truly believe it’s wrong (which, in this case, you’re probably right about).
Wolf, if you don’t think you did anything wrong then you are a shogeg.
The thing with babies and mirrors is that most people have NO idea why it is a minhag. What was the source for the Bubbeh Maiseh (which it totally is, but that does not make it a bad thing – our Bubbies were very wise). We do a lot of things that are Bubbeh Maisehs. But we do them, nonetheless, maybe on the chance that they are right. To me however, if Hashem didn’t say it shouldn’t be done, it probably is safe if we did, so stop worrying about gehennom.
Wolf, if you don’t think you did anything wrong then you are a shogeg.
I didn’t say that I don’t believe I did anything wrong. I said I don’t regret what I’ve done wrong. It’s a huge difference.
Example: I’ve been told that I am a moser because I called the cops when a neighbor’s car went off at 2AM and wouldn’t shut off for two hours. (No, I don’t know whose car it was… so I couldn’t just go tell the neighbor — and yes, given where I live, the overwhelming odds were that it was a Jew’s car.) Yes, halacha says I should have gone to a bais din before calling the cops (since I wasn’t in any physical danger), but I chose not to wake rabbonim at 4AM. As such, I am a moser. Nonetheless, I don’t regret the fact that I’ve called the cops.
The Wolf
What is the baby suppose to do if they want to press down their eyebrows and check their teeth from side to side?
If the baby looked, what do you do? Are you supposed to make the mirror look back at the baby?
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.