- This topic has 13 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated 15 years, 7 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
I would like to open up for discussion the topic of “today’s Jewish niguna” as some may say that today’s Jewish music is just so called Jewish but its only the words that is Jewish but the song is copied from the goyim. On the other hand we know that the kaliver rabbi adopted a song from a goiysha shepherd and turned it into a Jewish song, or that we sing marches that was originally from Napoleons army. or we have no problem listening to chazunim that wasn’t even shomer shabes. So where do we draw the line here?
Moti, you’re gonna get those who say it’s okay because it’s sung by a Jew and it’s holy words, and then you’re gonna get those who say that it’s terrible.
I find it funny when I hear songs I know sung as Jewish songs. I would find it hard to take them seriously, though.
The latest one I heard is called “Rabbi Nachman” and it’s funny if you ever heard the original…
oh boy! I used to debate this with my classmates in high school. This type of conversation never ends.
Yeah I also used to debate about it until I realised it’s a total waste of time- a person should have the sense and maturity to know what music he/she should be listening to and what not…simple as that…
nitallmr- I think it’s like that with everything like tznius also. Everyone is on their own level and he/she should decide what is on his/her level and always try to grow higher.
But postsemgirl, there’s the rub. There may be a point where someone who has striven to higher heights in tznius has “arrived”. But who is to say what the ultimate heimishkeit in Jewish music is?
tzippi- In tzinus everyone has their sensitivites and no one is able to say what sensitivity you are suppose to have the same as no one can tell you what your sensitivity should be to music.
Postsemgirl, the question continues to be begged: who’s to say YOUR sensitivities are better than mine? What IS higher in tznius, and music? Taste is definitely a factor in music – “al taam v’rei’ach ain lhisvakaeach” – yet might there not be some objective standards, just as there are in tznius?
Moti(!) I don’t get what your point is. You ask what people think. I think I pretty much summed it up and gave my opinion too. Do you want to argue? Cuz, I don’t. I don’t even listen to Jewish music, unless I’m at a wedding or something.
I don’t know “golus golus”, but some shepherds have very soulful tunes, so I would imagine it to be a haunting melody.
I only find it funny when I hear a song I know and the Jewish singer put Jewish words to the tune. If I didn’t know the original song, I’d probably look at it differently.
people are going to make music that people want to hear. If they wouldn’t make music like this kids would be listening to crazy goyish music
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.