“4) This thread was a non halachic thread at one point. You either didn’t grasp what was going on when you joined, or you deliberately contradicted yourself so as to not have to answer. I don’t know what you know or don’t know. But I do know what was going on here on these pages and have the reading comprehension to see that you are not answering what you claim you are answering. It is clear to me how Rav Moshe understands what makes a rsh”r. It is also obvious that you think there is many shitos to this and have no clarity on it. It is very straightforward as Rav Moshe puts it into a single phrase. If you didn’t bother to uncover how Rav Moshe understands rsh”r independent from hilchos eruvin, than you really shouldn’t be learning hilchos eruvin. So I am not dismayed by your claim to superior knowledge.”
What a bunch of mumble jumble. No Rav Moshe is a chidush and he himself said so. His opinion was kneged the poskim of yesteryear, but you wouldnt know it if I hit you over the head with it. Show me one posek that maintains that a city is 12 mil by 12 mil. Show me one posek that maintains that mefulash and mechuvanim is not the same thing (in regards to eruvin), as mentioned in the MA. There are so many more arguments that Rav Moshe made that are mechudash, but it is beyond your pay scale.
Menu