Dear Youdont,
This is my first time binge-posting since before Sukkos.
You literally have a contradictory answer to every statement.
You use Rav Dovid while saying his psak is irrelevant.
Rav Elyashiv was personally very close to Rav Dovid, yet you say he had nothing to do with him.
Rav Moshe was very clear about his opinions about Brooklyn Eruv, yet look at everything you post.
Rav Moshe wrote that he is forced to respomd, yet you say he agrees.
I’m getting bored of laughing at you,,,,,,,,,,,,,
I could answer every point, but there is no reason to.
We reached the end of the debate last time I posted and you didn’t even realize.
You have proven yourself a hypocrite.
I will post it again.
Rav Moshe clearly writes in the teshuva from 79 that it is all explained in Chelek Aleph. So clearly Rav Moshe’s opinion was not fluid. You just learned everything wrong.
I could go on about Odessa, Warsaw, Paris, Chicago, and LA. But I will save it for someone who appreciates honest criticism.
I don’t think I am right about anything. And I only know general ideas. But as soon as you entered this thread I saw that you were contradicting yourself. (As you have done in the past. But this thread was never really about halacha. You totally missed that. And it revealed to me, that you probably missed the halacha in all the other eruv threads as well.) So I took you to task. Once I realized that there would be no isolating your opinions from whatever anyone else posts, I started posting Rav Moshe’s opinion to hold you to some standard. I never imagined you would be so innovatively incapable of digesting Rav Moshe’s shitta.