1) You are either thickheaded or a liar. You are not answering Rav Moshe’s own words. I am not the one making up the numbers. So if you believe that these numbers should have been included in chelek aleph, ask it on Rav Moshe, not me. Anyone who skips the numbers because of the few words that you are harping on, is dishonest. And yes I did offer possible answers to your irrelevant fake argument.
2) You never learnt the Brooklyn Eruv teshuvah in chelek aleph. It simply has nothing to do with the issue at hand.
3) You again are trying to pass yourself off as one who is all knowing. You do not know the inyan and are trying to play catch up. You are not the one to arbitrate if I am wrong or not.
4) No you have continuously left out numerous issues, but this is very glaring. It is obvious that you do not learn much halacahah. It is simple. Rav Moshe maintained that his chiddush was correct but since other poskim disagreed with him he did want to issue a clear p’sak. Hence, those following other rabbanim are not really contradicting a clear p’sak of Rav Moshe. [In any case, even if Rav Moshe would be issuing a clear p’sak one should follow his rav notwithstanding Rav Moshe’s opinion.]
Menu