Reply To: The final word on Moshiach from the meisim (hopefully!)

@Emunas1 interesting way of understanding Rambam. And if Rambam would have said died instead of killed that would not negate yoshke?

How about Rambam says someone from bais dovid diligently learning Torah and doing mitzvahs etc. Surely that negates yoshke who chazal Rambam and rambaN state was never fit to be Moshiach even while alive?!?

Furthermore Rambam goes on to explicitly refer to Yoshke stating he was vulgar etc and killed by bais din….

You are very mistaken with your understanding of killed vs died…

In any event Rambam says those words on a bchezkas Moshiach only and states he loses his chazaka. Yoshke was never bchezkas Moshiach rachmana Litzlan…