Reply To: Problem with Melech HaMashiach from the Dead

Orthodox rabbi –
You are basing your shita re your theology on actual words your rebbe said .
That is totally within your rights .
But – and that is a HUGE but …. and super relevant to this whole discussion !
That only shows, and is a good example, that the Chabad Chassidim are basing themselves on their rebbes words , and develop their theology accordingly .
Which they should .
.
So the million dollar question here is – how is it possible to have an open and honest discussion about this theology WITHOUT an equally open and honest discussion of the originator of said theology?
Therefore I would venture to say that
IT IS IMPOSSIBLE to have a complete and honest discussion about this theology without fully including the one under whose leadership, AND WHEREFROM this theology ORIGINATED .
And as long we will be hamstrung by concerns of self censorship in this regard , this discussion is doomed to be fruitless.
My impression is that the so called meshichistim are the true followers of their rebbi .
When you read his public utterances , his sichot , his maamarim, and try and imagine that every word and action emanate straight from the RBSH”O, would you not be a meshichist ?
In my opinion al least , the Mashiach line with all that it entails come directly from their rebbe .
So how is it logically possible to have an all encompassing , honest debate / discussion without including the main originator of this theology ?