Reply To: What Happened To the Forum I Loved so Well?

” There is no Zionism just like there is no communist revolution.”
So you would say there’s no point in opposing communism today? Should all the people of China just have to fall in line and become communists because it’s a lost cause?

I think part of what Avira is getting at is that the inyan to us is not to eliminate all secular and MO Zionism, which we know would be impossible. The main concern now is how easily it’s permeating even the yeshivish world. For example, considering Israel to be a Jewish safe haven even though it’s abjectly more dangerous, considering Israel to be a fallback if things “go south” in America even though that risk is also greater in Israel, an obsession with aliyah that never would have existed 100 years ago, an implicit attribution of religious significance to Israel existing and even messianic implications, etc.