Reply To: No torah no jewish state

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee No torah no jewish state Reply To: No torah no jewish state

#2126189
Avram in MD
Participant

Always_Ask_Questions,

“Right now, unfortunately, I do not stop at that.”

“I am afraid that I would not (and most other people are probably in the same position).”

Why then would you advocate for a “shitta” that you openly acknowledge that you cannot follow, nor do you expect the vast majority of the olam to be able to follow? The end result of your advice to “Lakewood” would be a tremendous loss of Torah.

“As with everyone, I get my masorah from my Parents and Teachers. Most of them encouraged independent thinking and asking questions.”

So it’s not that your parents and teachers told you that your family/community shitta is to hold vehemently to a specific Rambam in opposition to how others pasken, but that you can be an “independent thinker” and pasken for yourself?