Reply To: Herzog’s column

Marx – there definitely were not. There were apostates, sure, meshumadim, intermarrying jews, etc…but they no longer called themselves jews. Even the reform originally eschewed the title jew and called themselves “germans of hebraic persuasion”

Name one group or even one individual jew before zionism who was not at all observant but called themselves jewish. THERE WERE NONE. it was invented ad hoc by zionists.

“Get over it”
My point is that it’s not within the parameters of the definition of jew. There are men who think that they are women. They are outside the true definition of women, so they’re fantasizing. There are people who call themselves jewish, who have jewish souls trapped in sinful tamei bodies, who think and act in ways that have no bearing on the title Jew.