Reply To: Herzog’s column

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Herzog’s column Reply To: Herzog’s column

#2095498

Avira > Dovid hamelech fought for Hashem. Zionists fight against Him

Ok, this makes sense. But before you were assigning guilt by association: chilonim are wrong, thus R Kook is wrong by associatign with them; Reformim are wrong, thus oilam does not need tikkun, etc, etc. The problem with this approach is that it takes you on a subjective route – you can easily accuse anyone you don’t like by association: MO are associated with Bible criticism; scientists with college parties; baalei tzedoka with communism; baalei batim with heartless capitalism; anti-zionists with anti-semites; Torah scholars with Nazarenes; etc, etc. You can choose any of the above just based on your own biases: some choose part of that list; others – the other part and none will be wiser.