Reply To: ikarei hadas

I didn’t pivot to another question. The question was, and is, of what value is emunah peshutah, when it is not the result of proper research and analysis. You compared it to belief in the American Revolution, to which I responded that, indeed, my faith in the revolution is not so strong, and I will not ascribe to it overdue significance.

What has prompted you to pivot from questions on faith to the emotional aspect of its denial?

Because you have failed to provide an adequate explanation, you find it necessary to accuse me of “just having a desire for emunah to be unreasonable.” I want it to be reasonable; you tried, several times, to give a non-answer: first by changing the subject to havchana, then via comparing it to the American Revolution, and now to accusing me because you don’t have the answer, and talking about how emotional Matan Torah is,

If you have the answer, please clearly provide it. If not, stop wasting my time.