Avira, notice your circular reasoning – when you consider someone not just a gadol bTorah but with “mesorah in line” (who defines the line?), then it is OK and you are humbly withholding your opinion. When something is done by a gadol bTorah without your mesorah in line, then you bring farfetched explanations about people’s behaviors and motivations with absolutely no humility – and defend positions against those held by the gadol you do respect. I think you are fooling yourself when you claim not to judge gedolim.
Menu