11 Responses

1. Its truly pythetic, its a total disgrace for such a low thing to take place in “yerushalayim iyr hakodesh”

2. “organized by the Eida”

   dont think so!! the other members of the badatz of the eida were not there nor the admorim [toldos ay,aharon etc.] that are part the eida.
   nor were any signs signed by the eida!!

3. Kiddush Hashem!

4. The strategy of the Eidah this year was to low-key the Parade, in order to minimize the publicity, which would have a negative impact on Hareidi youth. This is the Gerer Rebbe’s position.

   Meanwhile, they tried to work behind the scenes–unsuccessfully.

5. to #5 in what way(productive)..how did you come to this conclusion?

6. #4
   please!!
   this was not the reason!!

7. to #9 dont know why you are upset…didnt say any thing upsetting.. you said “its more efficient and productuive” we assume you are referrung to the toiave parade. how is it more efficient in regards to stop this enormous chilil hashem (yes lawrence yid, such parade is MAJOR ,SHEBE-MAJOR chilil hashem, not when someone makes some minor shebe minor negetive comment on tim russet, whoever he is see posts here.. http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/article.php?p=19656

8. to #11 we cant go to a whole disscussion on meaning of chillil hashem, (not the way lawrence yid and his friend undrestands it)and purpose of moiche b’rabin no matter how little the effect it will have, see gemorrah shabbos, mefoershim on “pinchus ben elozor heishiv es chamosi..” that by going and showing our tzar.. it reduces the “churen af on us”..which is not accomlished by sitting and learning..so, bach to our question,YES how can sitting and learning be MORE effective.now those who are fleisig learners they shouldnt go (dont know l’halacha me not posek,but even according to your shita)..now if you wont mind, from your postings way back ,you dont seem to be one who is concerned about more learning only about not hurting the sensetivities of those toiave guys.. so thats why we commented

9. to #11, #13 and all posters who have same shita (“degree of compassion” for mechaive koris, skila…) we have yet to see you should be moiche for kvod shomaim(chillil hashem)..every time there is a article condemming chilil hashem ,where there is a display of disregarding a mitzvoh in the torah whether private or kal v’chomer in public ,you posters always come out against the ehrliche yidden and in defense of oivre avairah…..you say ” i indeed am concerned about that” where can we see you are concerned about the eibishters “sensitivities?(l’shaber es huoisen, so to speak.).chillel hashem is not only when sone one does wrong bein adom l’chavairo, it is also bein adom l’mokom.now “kolhamchallel shem shomayin b’tzina…nifroim mimenu b’agoli” so what chilil hashem nobody sees, not mt russet, not thast goy he was afraid of (one of the posters)so we see from here chilil hashem is not dafeke some body see its one doing an avairoh and disregardes the eibishter ,im yisoser eish b’mistorinm v’unoiche lo areni (rama seuf alef)so we have those mechallei torah mechallel shem shomaim b’rabim and not just one perso but hundreds so the chililis ten fold (which all you non ehrliche posters dont seem to be concerne so we have to havr k’nekom just as much moichimb’rabin for ,yes,

10. RE: #14..yes we know dont make sense..hit button accidently before finnished proofreading .. so last 1/2 limbo..

11. to # 16..so why are you bothering ?