You can move out of New York City without a passport. No Passport is required to move to any of the other 49 states or the District of Columbia, or to various possessions of the United States.
Perhaps you are like the stereotypical New Yorker who believes that the civilized world ends when you cross the Hudson? And if the United States becomes hostile to Jews, where would you move other than Eretz Yisrael (if the USA goes nazi, the rest of the world will follow) , which has never required a passport from Jewish refugees.
So unless you plan to go touristing abroad, you can postpone renewing your passport .