Reply To: The Empty Wagon – great book, but berating specific frum Jews is assur

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee The Empty Wagon – great book, but berating specific frum Jews is assur Reply To: The Empty Wagon – great book, but berating specific frum Jews is assur

#1901994
HaKatan
Participant

no mesorah:
Regarding the Avnei Nezer, you can check out this link, if the mods allow it:

sorry

Regardless, it seems strange to ignore all the poskim going all the way back who do invoke the oaths as practical and in force, etc.

Not to mention, of course, the “Religious Zionists” themselves contend with the oaths rather than simply (and impossibly) declare them non-halachic as you still insist on trying.

Regarding your contention that nobody was talking about the oaths until the heretical founder of political Zionism:
1. Please see above. The Rambam, as mentioned, among many others did.
2. Until that heretic, there never was a hava amina to attempt to make a State due to that being, as everyone knew, a violation of the oaths.

Regarding your opinion of what the Satmar Rav said, your prior posts make it seem likely that you have never even opened up his sefarim, so it seems silly to attempt to discuss this.

Regardless, though, the poskim who ruled that the oaths are binding are obviously well known enough that even the “Religious Zionists” take the time to (fail pitifully in their attempts to) contend with the oaths being very much halachic.