Depends what Yeshiva you are going to and what you can spend but here are the essentials. Charles Tyrwhitt shirts (usually 3/$99) extra slim fit with cutaway collar are the most popular. Black Cole haan zerogrands are a very popular pair of shoes (usually $100-$150 on Amazon/Zappos possible to get for even less on a good sale. For pants, if you want to splurge you can get Lululemon abc pants ($128) or you can look at Zara or H&M for much more affordable slim dress/stretch pants ($35+) you can also try hatbox or emporio if your going to a more yeshivish place
Socks really depend on what yeshiva, either black or nice patterns, but dont get anything too bright because it looks stupid
Borsalino hats are obviously the most popular, their lowest end hat (also the most durable) goes for $195 last I checked at the borsalino store on ave J.
For davening jacket you want to get a nice blazer not just your old shabbos jacket, maybe try Emporio.
For shabbos you want a nice suit, if you don’t have one you might want to try The Suit Lady in Teaneck, all suits are $300, make sure to find a good tailor. Shabbos shoes are a must, leave the shabbos sneakers in Baltimore
Btw don’t listen to Joseph, he has no idea what hes talking about. He probably graduated from torah vodaas class of 1970. edited
Welcome to New York