simplesense, the rule that the only true juices are those of grapes and olives (not only for the purpose of brochos but also for shabbos and for hechsher lekabel tum’ah) seems to derive from and depend on the fact that in the ancient world these were the only fruits commonly juiced. People who juiced other fruits were considered odd, and “botloh daatom”. Since this is no longer the case, it is very likely that the rule is no longer valid, but we lack poskim with the breitkait to say so. (There are poskim who suggest that juicing oranges is nowadays assur mid’oraisa, but I have never heard of one who will also rule that orange juice is machshir lekabel tum’ah, or that its bracha is ha’etz, which should naturally follow.)
Menu