Reply To: Can the severity of a sin be learned from the severity of the punishment?

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Can the severity of a sin be learned from the severity of the punishment? Reply To: Can the severity of a sin be learned from the severity of the punishment?

#1786935
ubiquitin
Participant

“Call your lor for practical application”

I did, he is the one who says you never went to yeshiva.

“First off I’m not sure that someone Who performs an abortion is not חייב מיתה”

You should be. There is no shiya that I’m aware of that holds that regarding a Jew.

Regarding #1. So if not for Rashi you would be unsure, you’d havecahava Amina that sacrificing all children is better.
Your answer to #2 settles the conversay if your not sure whether being hit or having a leg cut off clearly we are operating in different universe s
Your dodging the question in #3 makes me feel a little better

Your comment regarding the Bunyan tziton is really upside down. Clearly punishment is not the some determinant. And as to your comment YES! Nailed it All other poskinm argue on the Bunyan tziton and cadaveric donations are routinely done and aren’t even halachicly controversial. Brain death on the other hand….