Those claiming that Josef is not fulfilling הוכח תוכיח because he is not a rabbi or something of that sort,
There is a huge difference between giving SOMEONE מוסר wherein one can lay claim to someone not Being in the proper position to be giving others musasr
Whereas discussing what you believe is the utopian ideal for your religion on an anonymous internet forum, anyone Is entitled to post their opinion.
Why not he is not “giving anyone mussar “.
Again I see a well developed, I’m my opinion, totally undeserved hatred towards Joseph.
And the only way I personally can understand it is that his positions get some people very nervous.
Which IMHO usually are more in line with authentic Judaism than most of the others here.
As a test, I’ll repeat a question I asked a while ago on a different thread, which got no answer there.
What should be the punishment for someone who is מאנס a woman who was previously married and is now divorced