CA
“But I wouldn’t be surprised if they held “it should have never been started””
Oh me neither, but that isnt the discussion.
As to the issue we ARE discussing , you said “No” So we are in perfect agreement.
“And I think that in essence it what joe was getting at, it just makes the thread more controversial the way joe worded it”
nope, He insisted (on that thread) that he meant it the way he wrote it, which you concede is NOT the standard charedi view today.
user 176
“Lol… I guess this thread is the exception?”
Nope
and FYI I only read until about the middle of your comment