“Neville, where did you ever hear that the Eidah HeChareidis posken’s that they’re safek Jews?”
When did you hear they don’t? They’re machmir in both directions, as I described. It clearly doesn’t make them any more meikel in their expectations for the geirus process.
“MH please tell us your source telling us there a source we can search isn’t a source please name the Gemara or I will assume you made it up”
I found it. See above.
RGP: “What does it matter what the Eidah thinks? How is that relevant?”
It shows that they aren’t vadai goyim according to any major de’os. You already established HaRav Ovadia Yosef’s opinion, which MH apparently doesn’t hold by. He seems to be assuming there are poskim out there who take his approach, but I do not know of any, nor has he brought any.