Reply To: Pilpul vs. Halacha

Home Forums Bais Medrash Pilpul vs. Halacha Reply To: Pilpul vs. Halacha

#1742532
Neville ChaimBerlin
Participant

I personally am of the opinion that the Slabodka/American yeshiva derech doesn’t teach enough halachah and the bochrim end up knowing less than baalhabatim. The fact that the derech halimud was set up by gedolim does not mean everyone has to think it’s best. Pressberg had a different derech, the Sphardim have a different derech, etc. It might just be the most popular because it’s the easiest.