Reply To: In Chad Gadya – HKBH was “wrong”

avreichamshlomo – “are you really calling klal yisrael the cause and Hashem the effect?” I specifically used mitzva and s’char or aveira and onesh to illustrate cause and effect. So bask in whatever intelligence leaks from me (or in your words “brain leaks”) and it might help you follow my writtings.

When we do a mitzva, we cause a “senaygor” (advocate) which causes an affect, namely s’char from Hashem. Are you following? No, I never claimed (and am clueless how you were able to concoct such a twisted notion that) that Hashem is “caused” by mitzvot or by Klal Yisroel.

Likewise, when a person does an avaira, he causes/creates a ketaygor (prosection) which causes him to get an onesh from HKBH. Is that a foreign concept to you?

Are you still confused, perplexed (as in Moreh Nevuchim)?

Savour the brain leakage and treasure whatever drops of intelligence you can absorb.