Reply To: Adama Veshamayim – Avoda Zara

Balance, when the other side is willing to have a “conversation” to discuss “deep halachic concepts” I am willing to have that “meaningful dialogue.”

But, when we’re talking halacha – and a simple fact-based shaila to boot – , and someone keeps throwing in extra-halachic concepts such as “balance” and “nuance” which are unclassifiable, undebatable, unprovable, and entirely based on emotion, and are very reminiscient of non-torah hashkafa of YCT and the reform movement, I will make fun of him

Even if it’s not so “subtle” and “nuanced.”

Kol letzunasa asura…. chutz…..

And this type of hashkafa fits this catagory better than adama veshamayim.