Reply To: Do I owe my neighbor kosher meat or treif meat?

She wants to take it back (any pound of meat in my pot) but I want to keep all the 61 lbs of kosher meat and give her back trief meat for her dog.

Let’s pretend she dropped a pound of kosher meat in the pot. Who says she could just take back any pound of meat in the pot? If I drop a basketball in your backyard, can I go into your backyard and just grab any basketball I find?

The burden is on her to prove that she’s taking back what’s hers. Until she can prove it, she gets nothing.