LerntminTayrah
“In fact, most Lubavitchers today are tinokos shenishbu, unable to see beyond the cult they were born into, and unable to read the ikrei emunah of the Rambam and realize how many are being violated regularly. ”
So if your not a dinok shenishbu
Please explain all the עיקרי האמונה and why Chabad violates them.
“1. Hashem alone runs the world, not in partnership with any Rebbe”
Agreed, but what does it mean Hashem runs the world? How does השגחה פרטית work with this that we have בחירה חופשית?
And btw we/yiddin are a shutif with a Hashem in creating the world, by us doing mitzvos we become a shutif with Hashem, (I forgot the exact loshon hamedrish)
Please explain.
“2. Hashem alone lives forever.”
Don’t think it’s the right way of butting it, Hashem is מחויב המציאות, he never had a תחילה to have a סוף. So it’s not really fit to say that on Hashem.
“3. Hashem has no physical form, so you can’t say atzmus melubash baguf”
No person and כ”ש someone that learns chassidus would ever say that, because עצמות is impossible to be מתלבש in פרטים because כל עצם בלתי מתחלק, so how would that make sense that it’s mislabesh in a guff, אלא מאי, you should find out what he meant, before coming with daynios
“4. You are only allowed to Daven to Hashem, nobody else”
100% I don’t know anyone that davens to a Rebbe, but I do know people daven by the ohel for him to be a mielitz yoisher for us.
5. If a person claiming to be moshiach dies, that’s it for his candidacy. Quoting gemaras about Yaakov Avinu lo meis or similar doesn’t change the fact that in metzius, the Rebbe was niftar and got buried 25 years ago.
Please explain what yakov avinu lo mies means, did he have a kevurah?
Learn the Gemorah, and the ein yakov thoroughly.
6. If someone claims to be a navi and makes multiple false prophecies about when moshiach is coming (a good prophecy), then that person is a navi sheker. Not hatred, halacha.
Please explain where you got this from, and what exactly did the Rebbe say.
“Like I said, they have forced and krum terutzim, and can fool regular people.”
Your personal opinion. Have you ever thought that you’re the fool?
(Especially comparing Chabad to Lev Tahor find me one godel that said that.)
“But that’s why we have gedolim, who can tell you not to listen to forced and krum teirutzim.”
Who told you and what exactly did he tell you?
I wonder why Rebbe Chaim kaniefsky had Rabbi Berel Lazarbin his office and accepted chabad chassidus seforim from him, (told his gabai to bring it to his room, so he can learn through the seforim.
Harav shtiemen told people to send thier kids to a chabad school (in Italy) and don’t make your own school.
Rabbi Lifshits spoke highly about chabad.
Rabbi Yerucham Olshin made such an effort to come from lakeood to Rubashkins chassuna, and you see him in a video dancing to Lubavitcher niginim.
And some Roshe Yeshiva (I forgot his name (the one that made a chierim against El Al a few months ago) is seen dancing with hundreds of Bochurim in a video dancing to a chabad nigun that was made in honor of the Rebbes birthday 40 years ago.
So many Rebbeim and Rebbelach came to see, and visit the Rebbe. Check the safer Chad bedorah.
I could go on and on, the point is, have you ever thought maybe chabad is not bad after all and it’s just bunch of loshin harah? or your going to call these rabbonim/Gedolim also tinoikos shinishbu, and supporting a cult??.
I don’t need you to go explain everything, my only point is, that if you have טענות, go to a respected Lubavitcher rov/mashia and ask him your questions, (if you takeh believe that you are not a hater,) instead of writing it here and black lashing an eda kidiesha
“Don’t listen to me, maybe I’m just a krum snag hater.”
Efsher takeh
“Listen to your gedolim, follow your mesorah.”
100%
That’s all I have got to say, have hatzlocha in all your endeavors.