Reply To: The world is in a state of Geula- and don’t misunderstand us!

Rso
” I have a long history of studying and questioning Lubavich, and not getting satisfactory answers to what started out as innocent questions – and I found them unacceptable.”

I would say that there are likely two reasons for this: 1) you are asking the wrong people. There are many extremely learned people in lubavitch, I can list some or maybe one of the menfolk who I’m sure are following silently along can provide a more extensive list if you are interested.

There are many regular chassidim who just accept what the Rebbe says as fact (remember you protesting what happened to Emunas chachamim?) and don’t think through logically what the actual question and answer is. The Rebbe bemoaned this by Farbrengens, when he addressed the lack of critical questions following his rashi sichos. But we definitely have many learned people, and also Roshei Yeshivos who were originally not lubavitch so they can appreciate the actual the questions and answers even more.

2) you have an extremely strong bias which precludes you from actually having a productive, intellectual, source based discussion with them.